Travelogue: Afghanistan
| Oren
Schlein shares his experiences first hand of Afghanistan, the
Taliban and the Adopt-a-Minefield program. |
by Oren Schlein, Executive
Director, Adopt-A-Minefield®
< 1 2>
Next Page
 |
| Although this compound near
Herat is only 5,632m2 in size, the demining teams
have had to deploy every type of clearance toll at their
disposal - manual deminers, mechanical demining machines, mine
detection dogs, and explosive ordnance disposal teams. |
In early July 2001, I traveled to the Afghan
cities of Kabul, Jalalabad, Herat, and Kandahar. The purpose of my trip was to
assess the status of our Adopt-A-Minefield® program in the country. I was
hosted by the Mine Action Program for Afghanistan (MAPA), which is a part of the
United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs in
Afghanistan (UNOCHA). This report was written after the terrorist attacks on New
York and Washington DC on September 11, 2001. Adopt-A-Minefield® is a program
of the United Nations Association of the USA.
Initial Impressions
My field mission to Afghanistan was longer
than most of my other visits to mine-affected countries. This was because of the
difficulty in obtaining authorization to travel in-country and the rather vast
distances between destinations. It took me over a month to obtain my visa to
enter Afghanistan and even once I arrived in Kabul, I had to visit a Taliban
office to obtain further internal visas to travel within the country. The
process of obtaining these visas was a small example of the extremely
bureaucratic nature of the Taliban regime.
Afghanistan has suffered such a complete and
extreme level of structural collapse over the past two decades of conflict that
Afghan society has been thrust back into a primordial age in which nobody takes
their daily survival for granted. Essential services that we take for granted in
our own societies, including health care and education, and basic infrastructure
are virtually non-existent in Afghanistan. The country has also suffered a
severe drought for the past four years. Even before the recent mass exodus of
Afghans from most urban centers following the September 11th
attacks on the United States and the subsequent military strikes on Afghanistan,
there were nearly four million Afghan refugees living in Pakistan and Iran, and
hundreds of thousands of internally displaced persons living throughout
Afghanistan. As recently as this summer, the United Nations and other
 |
| Sheepherder
from the village of
Deza, near Herat. The white markings on the buildings (in
background) indicate that the road has been cleared of mines.
The red markings indicate that the building itself is still
mined. |
international aid agencies were providing food and basic humanitarian services
to more than three million Afghans. The number of Afghans now in need of such
assistance has risen to over seven million, out of a population of 20-21 million
people.
In spite of the horrible human tragedy that
has afflicted the Afghan people in recent years, they are a remarkably
resilient, proud, and generous people. Everywhere we went, we were welcomed with
open arms and the heartfelt appreciation of those whose lives we have helped
through Adopt-A-Minefield®.
Background to Adopt-A-Minefield®
in Afghanistan
Afghanistan has been one of the most popular
and well managed Adopt-A-Minefield®
programs at the country level. This is because MAPA’s mine clearance program
in Afghanistan has been one of the best coordinated and implemented in the
world. The model established by the UN in Afghanistan during the 1990s has
served as an important example for developing and managing other national mine
action centers. Adopt-A-Minefield®
 |
| This site near Herat was cleared
with Adopt-A-Minefield® funds.
Deminers found 13 anti-tank mines and 8 UXO. |
joined the UN’s efforts to clear mines in Afghanistan in 1998. Since then,
over $550,000 has been raised through the collective fundraising efforts of
hundreds of individuals and groups in the United States and overseas for mine
clearance operations in the country. The sites included in the Adopt-A-Minefield®
portfolio represent a cross-section of the types of projects that MAPA
undertakes, both geographically and in terms of the types of clearance tools
used. We have funded the clearance of sites in the Central, Western, Eastern,
and Southern Regions of Afghanistan, and we have plans to support clearance
operations in the Northern Region. The diversity of land and topography in
Afghanistan is truly remarkable. The skills required to clear all these areas is
equally diverse.
MAPA uses four main types of demining
resources, including manual clearance teams, mechanical clearance teams, mine
detection dogs, and explosive ordnance disposal teams. Afghanistan has about 50
percent of the world’s mine detection dogs, and a majority of our
Adopt-A-Minefield® sites are
cleared with these dogs. MAPA incorporates a toolbox approach in its
clearance operations, which means that it often uses two or more demining
techniques in its work to improve the efficiency of its demining operations.
Effective implementation of this approach also results in significant cost
savings.
Kabul: 3-5 July 2001
Because of the United Nations sanctions on
Afghanistan, all flights in and out of the country are run by the UN, which
bases its operations out of Islamabad. The flight path over Kabul is over the
Hindu Kush mountains, which are a stunning introduction to Afghanistan and no
preparation for the devastation below. By air, one is welcomed to Kabul by the
sight of derelict and abandoned buildings, and bombed out planes, tanks, and
other remnants of war surrounding the rudimentary runway. No effort has been
made to remove these obsolete planes and tanks from the airfield. The terminal
itself is a dark, empty, and depressing structure with no electricity and dozens
of broken windows. Although a handful of Taliban security don’t appear
terribly interested in our arrival, I am rather nervous about the fact that I am
carrying camera equipment with me, as the Taliban prohibit any photography of
live beings, including people and animals. The penalty for being caught is
imprisonment.
Our First Security Briefing
The first thing we did upon our arrival at the
guesthouse was receive a security briefing. It was perhaps the most important
meeting we had in each city we visited because it alerted us to any security
problems in the area — perhaps fighting among the Taliban and the Northern
Alliance forces, or bandits operating outside the city centers — and what
specific evacuation plans were in place in the event we needed to quickly leave
the area.
The Taliban Ministry of Interior is the
security focal point in Afghanistan. It is responsible for looking after the
armed Taliban guards posted outside the UN compounds with their Kalashnikovs —
ostensibly to ‘protect’ the UN staff. In Kabul alone, there are several UN
compounds, each housing a different UN office. The Taliban were constantly
threatening to evict the UN from these compounds, and negotiating with the
Taliban had become a great source of frustration to all UN staff. It had become
commonplace for high-level UN officials to spend a majority of their time
dealing with administrative issues of this sort, taking them away from the
humanitarian assistance work that they sought to provide to the Afghan
population.
We were told to avoid the Taliban ‘guests’
Arabs, Pakistanis and Chechens who came to Afghanistan for terrorist training.
This includes not even driving anywhere near their compounds or in areas where
they are known to be. Foreigners are told not to accept invitations to Afghan
homes. On several occasions, we were invited to dine in their homes, but we did
not accept any of these invitations, as the penalty for doing so is imprisonment
for the Afghan hosts. Foreigners are also imprisoned, but usually released
within hours. Afghans are frequently detained for several days and the detention
has been described to me as an ‘unpleasant experience.’
The Vice and Virtue
In the weeks before our visit, there had been
several incidents monitored by the UN security officer in Kabul, some of which
had made it into the international press. Most of these involved the Ministry
for the Prevention of Vice and the Promotion of Virtue the Vice and Virtue, or
religious police, as they are more commonly known. They are a constant source of
fear to the local Afghan population.
The Vice and Virtue had been particularly
active in Kabul in the two months prior to our visit. A couple of foreign
workers from the Comprehensive Disabled Afghans’ Program, a landmine survivor
assistance clinic, had been detained for three days because they had been caught
with music tapes in their cars — a ‘vice’ prohibited by the Taliban. Other
vices include owning televisions, video players and satellite dishes, clapping,
and singing. Foreigners can be jailed up to 14 days, and Afghans can be detained
up to six months and have the power to their homes cut off for any of these
offenses.
|
One of my lasting impressions of
Afghanistan is that although the country is beleaguered and the situation
often grim, the Afghan people display great fortitude in the face of all
their difficulties. Theirs is a very proud can-do attitude and they are
unfailingly grateful for any help they receive. I met a number of
committed UN employees and brave and resolute deminers during my visit.
Afghans are very fond of proverbs and seem to have one for every
situation. While we were in Jalalabad, the head of the Mine Detection and
Dog Centre shared a poignant proverb with the graduates of the Monitoring,
Evaluation and Training Agency, which summed up the efforts of all
deminers, aid workers, and donors: ‘A person who saves one life saves a
society.’ |
A few days before my arrival in Kabul, the
Taliban had scaled the walls of one of the UN compounds, with their Kalashnikovs
in hand. They spent 15 minutes rifling through the premises, having a good look
at all the rooms, equipment, and fixtures. Shortly after their departure, the
head of the UN regional office received a call from a senior Taliban official
informing her that the UN had 15 days to vacate the premises. This bullish
attitude is very typical of the Taliban’s treatment of the UN and other
 |
| Children from the village of
Surkhab, Logar Province,
which suffers from severe mine
contamination and a four-year-old drought. |
foreign aid agencies. This particular story had a better ending than most — UN
staff engaged in several late night discussions with their Taliban counterparts,
explaining their legal rights of abode and that it was in the best interests of
the Afghan people that the UN be permitted to remain in the compound so that
they could continue their work. The sense of exasperation that I heard from many
UN workers related to the fact that the Taliban had a habit of making impulsive
decisions without considering all the facts and consequences of their actions
beforehand.
In spite of the widespread fear, anxiety, and
repression that they engender, the Vice and Virtue can also be a source of
bemusement to the local population. On our way back to the UN guesthouse, we
passed a contingent of Vice and Virtue in their archetypal black Toyota pickup
truck — the vehicle of choice among the religious police. They were driving
through the streets of Kabul shouting at the locals through speakers mounted on
the top of their truck. As we passed them, I noticed that my Afghan host was not
wearing his turban. This is an essential requirement for every Afghan male. He
turned to our driver with a big grin on his face and told him to drive faster. I
asked him whether or not he was concerned about being stopped and he proceeded
to laugh out loud and tell me that the Vice and Virtue were essentially a ‘bunch
of clowns.’
 |
| A deminer provides a security
briefing near the village of Jowkan, three hours south of
Jalabad. Although deminer have not yet found any mines in this
particular area local villagers will not use the land because
two people were killed by an anti-tank mine in a nearby field
several years ago. |
Meeting the Taliban
We had a meeting scheduled with the Office of
Disaster Preparedness, which includes the Department of Mine Clearance, the
official Taliban entity responsible for setting demining priorities along with
the UN Mine Action Center for Afghanistan. We were warmly greeted by eight
Taliban officials. We removed our shoes, exchanged handshakes, hugs, and smiles,
and were seated at a long rectangular table. I introduced myself and explained
the Adopt-A-Minefield® program to
my hosts. They were pleased that so many of our Adopt-A-Minefield®
donors had supported mine clearance efforts in Afghanistan. With the money we
had raised in 2000, we were among the top ten donors for mine clearance in
Afghanistan, and the only non-governmental organization in this category. It was
a point that was not lost on my Taliban hosts. It also didn’t appear to matter
much whether the donors were American or European, so long as we were all
helping the Afghan people.
At one point in the meeting, however, I heard
the interpreter emphasize to the Taliban the fact that I was from New Zealand
and not the United States. As a dual national, I chose to travel to Afghanistan
on my New Zealand passport, given the sensitive political climate in the region.
It turns out that in spite of my best efforts to talk cricket and rugby — the
 |
| The village of Lala Qala, near
Jalabad, has witnessed 50 mine accidents. In 22,00m2
area of agricultural land, deminers recently found 26
anti-personnel landmines and three unexploded
ordnance. |
national sports in New Zealand — I never fooled them. I have it on good
authority that the Taliban use their close connections with the ISI, the
Pakistan Inter-Services Intelligence, to investigate foreign visitors and they
knew before I even entered the country that I was American. At that moment, I
reflected upon a conversation I had had with the former U.S. Ambassador to
Pakistan a few days earlier in Islamabad, in which he informed me that if
anything happened to me while in Afghanistan, there was nothing the U.S.
Government could do to protect me.
Regional Mine Action Center
After our meeting with the Taliban officials,
we met with representatives from the Kabul Regional Mine Action Center (RMAC).
The Kabul RMAC is the organization responsible for overseeing the survey and
clearance of mined areas in the Central Region of Afghanistan. It works closely
with the national Mine Action Center in Islamabad and with its implementing
partners — those nongovernmental organizations that specialize in mine
clearance, survey work, mine awareness, and survivor assistance.
Our first visit was a tour of the headquarters
and kennels of the Mine Detection and Dog Center (MDC) in Kabul. This
organization was established in 1989 and is recognized as one of the most
advanced mine detection dog organizations in the world. It works under the
auspices of UNOCHA and MAPA. Originally funded by the United States, MDC is now
funded by Germany. MDC’s objectives are to clear priority mined areas and to
survey suspected mined areas. It has its own breeding program with more than 100
dogs and operates in four of Afghanistan’s five regions.
The Village of Merza Khail
On the Fourth of July, we ventured into our
first mine field, an area known as AFG-070 (a number designated by
Adopt-A-Minefield®), which was
being cleared by MDC. During the Soviet occupation, Russian forces used the main
road near Merza Khail to travel between a nearby military base, which housed a
rocket depot, and the Pakistan border. The road was heavily mined by the
Mujahedeen to deter the Russians, and today all the villages in the area are
suffering the consequences of this mine contamination.
During our visit, we met with seven village
elders. They told us that many mine accidents still occur along the road and
near the village. Several children have been maimed and killed by mines in
recent years and, as a result, they are confined to specific areas in and around
the village. Villagers have also found mines while ploughing the arid fields
behind the village and many animals have been lost to mines. Even the village
well was mined during the war, rendering the village’s main water source
unusable.
When I asked how old the village was, I was
told that it was ‘five or eight great-grandfathers old.’ Before the Soviet
occupation, 80 families of five or six people each lived in the village. Now,
only 20 families remain, with most having left the area and settled as refugees
in Pakistan. With regard to the mine problem, Niamatuwllah, the village elder,
explained that his village has a home-based school for boys, not girls, which
incorporates mine awareness into its curriculum. He also mentioned that the
school only teaches the Koran, and no secular subjects. In addition, the
deminers working in the area provide mine awareness training sessions two times
a week to the children and men. This effort to increase local awareness about
the mine problem is part of a countrywide effort in Afghanistan to integrate
mine awareness into the activities of demining organizations. Because of the
Taliban prohibition on women receiving any form of education, and certainly any
form of training by men, the mine action community in Afghanistan has
established female mine awareness teams based in the cities that travel to the
villages to instruct women on the dangers of mines. The reality is that women
rarely venture out of their homes or villages, so the immediate threat of mine
injuries is significantly less to them than it is to men and children.
The Clearance Process
MDC was halfway through clearing the road
around Merza Khail when we visited. They had a five-week-long clearance plan, in
which they expected to clear 117,523m2,
a five-kilometer stretch of land about 25-30 meters wide. Mine Dog Group 7, or
MDG7 as it is known, is led by Taj Mohammed, the group leader. His group is
split into two sections of six deminers each, two dogs with handlers, and one
section leader. In addition, MDG7 has one paramedic and two drivers to assist
with medical emergencies, transportation of the deminers and their equipment,
and other logistical requirements.
As with most mine clearance operations, this
particular demining project was slow, tedious, and dangerous. The demining teams
mark off a base line from which to operate and deploy the dogs along an
eight-meter-long leash. They are trained to sit in place if and when they detect
anything suspicious, at which point the dog handler calls the section leader to
the area. The section leader marks a two-square-meter area, using the dog’s
position as the center point. The dog is given a blue ball as a reward for his
efforts and the manual deminers are then called in to clear the area.
A Glimpse into the Soviet Occupation—the
Village of Surkhab
Following our visit to Merza Khail, we drove
15 minutes south to the village of Surkhab, along a shelled road with large,
deep artillery craters. The sites that have been scheduled for clearance lie
along both sides of the road. Before the drought, the entire region was fertile
agricultural and grazing land. Now, it is a massive, dry lakebed. Most of the
area is littered with landmines, particularly anti-tank mines laid by the
Mujahedeen to protect their positions against advancing Russian troops. There
have also been several accidents along the road, including children injured
while playing with mines and unexploded ordnance. The net effect of the drought
and mine problem on the village of Surkhab is that three-quarters of the 90
families in the village have left the area. Twenty families remain; the rest are
refugees in Pakistan.
The village is ‘three fathers old’ about
100 years. It has suffered extensive hardship over the past 20 years. In 1980,
the Russians attacked all the villages in the valley, but Surkhab suffered
particularly badly. The Russians conducted repeated aerial bombings of the
village because it was home to several Mujahedeen fighters. At one point, the
Russians raided the village for five continuous hours, shooting a dozen men,
women, and children, and taking all the animals.
Following this incident, most of the villagers
abandoned their homes, heading for the hills above or fleeing the valley for
Pakistan. Tragically, four villagers, all Mujahedeen, remained behind. They were
captured by the Russian forces and locked in the village Mosque, a simple room,
which was set afire. Three died and one was severely injured. Their fellow
villagers witnessed the incident through binoculars. The three victims are
martyrs to the Afghan jihad, or holy war, against the Russians. The Mosque in
which they died is now a mausoleum to Tela Mohamed, Berget, and Lal Gul. The one
survivor, Hazart Gul, now lives as a refugee in Iran.
|
Emergency, a landmine survivor assistance clinic
The Vice and Virtue had scaled the walls of Emergency, with their
Kalashnikovs, on May 17, 2001. They were upset by reports of men and
women eating together in the clinic’s cafeteria. Rather than approach
the clinic’s administrators and investigate the alleged incidents,
they beat up local staff and foreigners, arrested several workers, and
shut down the clinic, which had only recently opened. Emergency had an
annual budget of $1 million and had built a state-of-the-art facility in
Kabul. They have similar clinics in other mine-affected countries and
have provided medical services, including complex life-saving surgeries,
to 200,000 people — about 20-25 percent of whom are mine survivors —
worldwide over the past seven years. The Kabul clinic was to have been
one of the better sources of medical care in Afghanistan, supported by
several first aid posts around the country. Since the raid, it has sat
idle and vacant.
|
Za Zai, the village elder who told me this
story, said that village life was forever changed by this incident. Most of the
villagers who lived in refugee camps during the Soviet occupation of Afghanistan
now have established lives in Afghan communities in Pakistan. Surkhab receives
no food or other assistance from aid agencies. Most of the villagers work as
laborers in Pakistan and Iran to support their families. The average laborer in
Afghanistan earns $0.80 a day; in Pakistan, they can earn over $1 a day. This is
still less than the $4 a day necessary to feed a family of 8-10 people, but with
multiple family members working, most villagers just manage to survive.
RMAC has surveyed the area around Surkhab and
identified 160,000m2 of land that
will need to be cleared to accommodate the needs of the entire village. In the
process of surveying the land, the deminers found one anti-tank mine by the side
of the road. As a result, the villagers are more vigilant than ever, they
welcome mine awareness teams to their village, and they carefully monitor the
movements of their children.
< 1 2>
Next Page
|